Abstract
In our original article, we tried to get theologians to reexamine markets as a way of organizing economic activity by suggesting that markets may be part of Gods providential care of human beings. Professor Dempsey challenged our appropriation of providence to describe the market system. In our subsequent responses to each other, there has been some narrowing of the divide between us, but a wide gap remains. Given a limited amount of space, we will focus on three elements that still divide and must rely on the readers access to the previous articles to fill in some gaps.